Police Companies Board should meet larger bar of transparency

Article content material

Final week’s resignation of Dr. Gail Beck as chair of the Ottawa Police Companies Board, following the arrest of her 37-year-old son, Timon Beck, throughout a significant drug bust, is a loss, each for the board and the town. With rising scrutiny on police involvement in incidents the place mental-health points are at play, Dr. Beck’s lengthy historical past of neighborhood service and her advocacy for girls’s and youngsters’s psychological well being made her a welcome addition to the board when she was tapped for the place final April.

Article content material

Her resignation from that submit was additionally unquestionably the precise factor to do, given the circumstances. It could have been untenable for her to proceed to chair the general public physique that oversees the Ottawa Police Service whereas her son, residing on the similar tackle as a part of his bail circumstances, faces such critical prison fees. The optics merely disqualify her.

Article content material

The board’s announcement of her resignation, nevertheless, ought to have been dealt with very in another way, with not less than some small measure of transparency.

“Earlier immediately,” the board quietly posted on its web site final Thursday, “the Board obtained the resignation of Dr. Gail Beck from the Ottawa Police Companies Board, efficient instantly, citing private causes. Vice Chair Salim Fakirani (a provincial appointee to the board), has assumed the function of Appearing Chair.

“The Board needs to convey its appreciation for the dedication and contributions of Dr. Beck during the last seven months in her function as Chair,” it continued. “The Board won’t be offering any additional touch upon this matter.”

It was terse and cursory, reflecting greater than a whiff of authorized recommendation. “Nothing to see right here,” is what it stated, which, in fact, solely makes individuals wish to look a bit more durable, and it wasn’t all that troublesome for reporters to find the hyperlink between mom and son. With every other municipal board or committee, that sort of perfunctory press launch may be all that’s required. If a member of the Planning Advisory Committee, for instance, discovered herself in the identical scenario and felt she may now not fulfil her tasks, then by all means step down for private causes and let that be the tip of it.

Article content material

But it surely was the chair of the police board whose son was criminally charged. Issues in regards to the police and police oversight board are understandably underneath a strong microscope, particularly in recent times. Confidence in police reached a low in the course of the convoy occupation, and Chief Eric Stubbs has repeatedly underlined the significance of incomes again public belief. However the Police Companies Board isn’t serving to issues — not by its personal efficiency in the course of the convoy, which was criticized in a February report by metropolis auditor common Nathalie Gougeon, who cited, amongst different points, the board not understanding its function, and its “diminished transparency”; and never by the board’s choice earlier this 12 months that delegations at public conferences should submit their feedback prematurely for overview; and positively not by its tight-lipped announcement of Beck’s departure.

Admittedly, issues had been most likely transferring at lightning pace because the arrests unfolded, and it ought to be acknowledged that Timon Beck has solely been charged; nothing has been examined or proved in court docket.

Moreover, there’s no suggestion that the (largely) arm’s-length relationship between the police and police board was compromised. Stubbs on Monday burdened that police don’t share operational particulars with the board, besides in circumstances involving massive protests and visits by dignitaries, each of which may have important impacts on the to-and-fro’ing of residents. That Dr. Beck comfortably sat beside Stubbs on the Dec. 6 council assembly to debate the police funds, throughout which the chief hinted on the pending announcement of arrests within the drug investigation — although not Timon Beck’s, which was introduced eight days later — means that Dr. Beck was not within the loop in regards to the case.

Article content material

I really feel unhealthy for Stubbs. He’s the one who’s been responding to media questions for the reason that arrest and resignation, when the duty to debate Dr. Beck’s departure largely ought to fall to the board. Maybe, although, it hasn’t completed studying the AG’s report from February, as a result of it’s not clear that it’s realized a lot about transparency. The board has an obligation to be forthcoming in regards to the occasions surrounding Dr. Beck’s resignation. All of us really feel for the nice physician, however we should know the info.

[email protected]

The Citizen newsroom is proud to report tales that matter to you. To help Bruce Deachman’s work and our mission to share info that retains you plugged into life in Ottawa, contemplate buying a digital subscription. https://www.ottawacitizen.com/subscribe

Article content material