San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors on Tuesday joined a lot of California cities and municipalities in voting in favor of a decision calling for a cease-fire to the hostilities within the Gaza Strip.
The decision, permitted on an 8-3 vote, requires a “sustained ceasefire in Gaza, humanitarian help, launch of hostages, and condemning antisemitic, anti-Palestinian, and Islamophobic rhetoric and assaults.”
Board President Aaron Peskin and Supervisors Connie Chan, Joel Engardio, Myrna Melgar, Dean Preston, Hillary Ronen, Ahsha Safai and Shamann Walton voted in favor. Supervisors Matt Dorsey, Rafael Mandelman and Catherine Stefani had been opposed.
“I do know this decision, some folks suppose it’s not going to do something,” Safai mentioned. “It is going to permit some folks in our communities to really feel heard and seen for the very first time … in our metropolis.”
The decision requires an finish to “the focusing on of civilians” and estimates that about 1.7 million Palestinians have been displaced whereas a whole bunch of 1000’s extra “are at imminent danger in Gaza” with no cease-fire. The decision additionally acknowledges the hazard for the roughly 137 Israelis saved hostage by the militant group Hamas.
Hamas launched an assault Oct. 7 that killed roughly 1,200 folks and led to the kidnapping of greater than 200. Israel’s response, backed by U.S. funding and weapons, is believed to be accountable for at the very least 22,000 Palestinian deaths to this point.
San Francisco joins fellow Northern California cities Richmond and Oakland in passing resolutions calling for a cease-fire. Richmond is believed to have been the primary U.S. metropolis to name for a cessation of preventing, on Oct. 25, whereas Oakland took motion on Nov. 27.
A lot smaller Cudahy was the primary Southern California metropolis to name for a cease-fire, on Nov. 7.
Leaders in different cities listened to spirited debates however in the end declined to go comparable resolutions, as was the case in Santa Ana on Dec. 5.
Cudahy’s decision mentioned Palestinians had “lived below violent and dehumanizing circumstances.” Richmond’s decision accused the state of Israel of “ethnic cleaning” and the battle crime of “collective punishment.”
San Francisco’s decision pointed to the USA authorities’s position in battle because it “supplies substantial army funding to Israel.”
It additionally known as on “the Biden Administration and Congress to name for a ceasefire, humanitarian help, and the discharge of all hostages.”
“We’re going to start out one thing right here immediately that’s going to take off throughout cities all around the United States,” supervisor Ronen mentioned. “And if sufficient of us converse out, President Biden must pay attention.”
No public remark interval for the decision was held Tuesday. As an alternative, practically 200 folks spoke at Monday’s Guidelines Committee assembly, and practically 400 attended the assembly in individual throughout a public remark interval Dec. 5, with all however one speaker voicing help for a cease-fire.
“We’ve by no means seen this stage of engagement and keenness and so many individuals coming ahead to share their views on this,” mentioned Preston, the decision’s writer. “And it’s not nearly folks coming in and talking, it’s about folks sharing such intensely private and emotional experiences.”
On Tuesday, chanting, booing and yelling might be heard contained in the supervisors’ chambers from a small viewers there and a a lot bigger one outdoors.
Dorsey, who opposed the measure and unsuccessfully tried to amend the decision in committee on Monday, was booed the loudest. At one level, the supervisors’ chamber was practically cleared as a result of disruptions.
Dorsey mentioned he couldn’t vote for the decision as a result of it did not condemn Hamas’ Oct. 7 assault. Its adoption would “ship a harmful and unthinkable message that terrorism works,” Dorsey mentioned.
Equally, Stefani mentioned she “received’t keep silent in regards to the risk” of Hamas, which she recommended employed sexual assault towards girls throughout its Oct. 7 raid.
“I’ll get up for ladies and ladies each time, it doesn’t matter what threats could come my method,” she mentioned. “You can not name for a cease-fire with out calling for the give up and removing of Hamas and the return of all of the hostages.”
After an hour of debate, applause rang out from the gang because the board voted in favor of the decision.
“We stood up even when it was exhausting, even once we had been threatened with political repercussions, which all of us have been,” Ronen mentioned. “I simply should say that immediately is a kind of days the place it looks like San Francisco remains to be right here. We’re nonetheless San Francisco.”
